Re-Eh

Pisqa’ 55

Pisqa’ 551

1

“And it shall happen, when HASHEM your God brings you” (Dt.11:29)—

and it shall happen implies immediately.

“When HASHEM your God brings you” (Dt.11:29)—

accept upon yourselves the commandment

stated in this scriptural context,

as a reward for which you shall enter the Land.2

“Which you are entering there to inherit” (Dt.11:29)—

as a reward for entering it,

you shall inherit it.

2

“And you shall place the blessing on Mt. Gerizim” (Dt.11:29).

Now, what is this verse trying to teach us—

that the blessing is from Mt. Gerizim,

and the curse is from Mt. Ebal?

But [don’t we know this,]

since it is already stated:

These tribes shall stand to bless the people on Mt. Gerizim,

and those tribes shall preside over the curse on Mt. Ebal” (Dt.27:12)?

But still, what does the Teaching add by stating:

“You shall place the blessing on Mt. Gerizim (Dt.11:29)?”

Now, might it not have been possible

for all the blessings to precede the curses?

But the Teaching states:

“You shall place the blessing on Mt. Gerizim” (Dt.11:29)—

a single blessing might precede a single curse,

but a series of blessings should not precede a series of curses!

3

Moreover, by juxtaposing curses and blessings, we learn that

just as the curses are uttered by Levites (cf. Dt.27:14),

so blessings are also uttered by Levites;

just as curses are uttered in a loud voice (cf. Dt.27:14),3

so blessings are also uttered in a loud voice;

just as curses are uttered in the Holy Tongue,

so blessings are uttered in the Holy Tongue;

just as curses are framed as general rules and their particulars,

so blessings are framed as general rules and their particulars;4

just as with curses, both groups respond, “Amen” (cf. Dt.27:15ff.);

so with blessings, both groups respond, “Amen.”

Finally, during the blessing,

both groups turn their faces toward Mt. Gerizim,

and, during the curse,

toward Mt. Ebal.

  1. H:112-113; JN1:179-180.
  2. This commonplace of rabbinic thought appears often in Sifre, e.g., Pisqa’ot 75.1, 156.1, 170.1, etc.
  3. Cf. T. Sotah 8:10.
  4. //M. Sotah 7:2.