Devarim (Pisqa'ot 1-25)

Pisqa’ 23

Pisqa’ 231

1

“And they took in their hands some of the fruit of the Land” (Dt.1:25).

Said R. Shimon:

What contemptible people!

For they grabbed with their hands!2

Like a person who grabs figs or grapes for an issar

that’s how they grabbed with their hands!

2

“And they brought it down to us” (Dt.1:25).

This indicates that

the Land of Canaan is higher

than all other lands,

in line with what is said:

“Let us ascend immediately, and take possession of it!” (Nu.13:30).

[And it says:]

”And they ascended and scouted the Land” (Nu.13:21),

[for it is said:]

Ascending via the Negev” (Nu.13:22),

[and, finally:]

”And they ascended from Egypt” (Gn.45:25).

“And they proposed, saying: Good is the Land

that HASHEM our God is giving to us!” (Dt.1:25).

Now, did they really say good things about it?

Actually, they said evil things about it!

Who said good things?

Only Joshua and Caleb.

Nevertheless:

“But you did not consent to ascend,

and you defied the utterance of HASHEM your God.” (Dt.1:26).

  1. H:44-45; JN1:60
  2. See Pisqa’ 20.2.